As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure

Best Toasters Under $200: 7 Spec-Based Picks

Latest update:

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.

We compared 7 pop-up toasters that cost between $150 and $200 when we checked; models from $100 to $150 are in our under-$150 list. Our top pick is the Breville BTA820XL: its motorized Lift & Look and A Bit More buttons let you check and adjust toast without restarting, in a compact die-cast body. The KitchenAid KMT4109 is the 4-slice choice, the Smeg TSF01 the style pick, the All-Clad TJ883D51 the touchscreen option, the HeatMate uses fast graphite heating and the Kenmore Elite automates a long slot. Picks are based on listings, not testing.

Our top pick: Breville 2-Slice Die-Cast Smart Toaster.

Quick picks

#ProductBest forPrice
1 Breville 2-Slice Die-Cast Smart Toaster Best overall Precise everyday toast Check price of Breville 2-Slice Die-Cast Smart Toaster on Amazon
2 KitchenAid 4-Slice Pro Line Automatic Toaster, KMT4109, Cast Iron Black | Fits Bagels, English Muffins, Thick Breads, Seven Shade Settings, Metal Housing, Auto Lift Lever Best 4-slice Households of four Check price of KitchenAid 4-Slice Pro Line Automatic Toaster, KMT4109, Cast Iron Black | Fits Bagels, English Muffins, Thick Breads, Seven Shade Settings, Metal Housing, Auto Lift Lever on Amazon
3 Smeg 2-Slice Toaster Red Best retro Design-led kitchens Check price of Smeg 2-Slice Toaster Red on Amazon
4 All-Clad Stainless Steel Toaster, 2 Slot, Removable Crumb Tray, 850 Watts, 7 Browning Levels, Intuitive Touchscreen, Extra High Lift, Silver Best touchscreen Minimalist kitchens Check price of All-Clad Stainless Steel Toaster, 2 Slot, Removable Crumb Tray, 850 Watts, 7 Browning Levels, Intuitive Touchscreen, Extra High Lift, Silver on Amazon
5 HeatMate Large 2-Slice Graphite Toaster Best fast toast Rushed mornings Check price of HeatMate Large 2-Slice Graphite Toaster on Amazon
6 Kenmore Elite 4-Slice Long Slot Toaster Silver, One-Touch Auto-Lift, Stainless Steel, Adjustable Browning, Defrost, Digital Countdown Timer, Retractable Cord, Toast, Bagels, Waffles, English Muffins Best long slot Long artisan slices Check price of Kenmore Elite 4-Slice Long Slot Toaster Silver, One-Touch Auto-Lift, Stainless Steel, Adjustable Browning, Defrost, Digital Countdown Timer, Retractable Cord, Toast, Bagels, Waffles, English Muffins on Amazon
7 Waring Extra-Long Slot 4-Slice Toaster Also great Busy kitchens Check price of Waring Extra-Long Slot 4-Slice Toaster on Amazon

The best fit for you

Our 7 picks

Best overall

Breville 2-Slice Die-Cast Smart Toaster

Best for: Precise everyday toast

Capacity
2 Slice
Wattage
900 Watts
Cooking Function
Toast
Color
Stainless Steel
Intended Use
Bagels
Dimensions
11.6 × 8.58 × 7.52 inches

View on Amazon: Breville 2-Slice Die-Cast Smart Toaster Affiliate link

The Breville BTA820XL is a brushed stainless die-cast 2-slice toaster with wide slots, variable browning, one-touch motorized lowering, Lift & Look to check toast without stopping the cycle, A Bit More to add time, and bagel and defrost functions; it weighs 5.71 lb.

Pros

  • Lift & Look checks without cancelling
  • A Bit More adds a little time
  • Compact die-cast body

Cons

  • Right at the $200 limit
  • Slot width not given in inches

Good fit if

  • You want the smartest 2-slice controls

Skip if

  • You need four slices

Verdict: Our top pick from $150 to $200.

Best 4-slice

KitchenAid 4-Slice Pro Line Automatic Toaster, KMT4109, Cast Iron Black | Fits Bagels, English Muffins, Thick Breads, Seven Shade Settings, Metal Housing, Auto Lift Lever

Best for: Households of four

Size
4 Slice
Intended Use
Bagels
Dimensions
11.4 × 11.8 × 8.3 inches
Weight
7.4 pounds

View on Amazon: KitchenAid 4-Slice Pro Line Automatic Toaster, KMT4109, Cast Iron Black | Fits Bagels, English Muffins, Thick Breads, Seven Shade Settings, Metal Housing, Auto Lift Lever Affiliate link

The KitchenAid KMT4109BK Pro Line in cast iron black is a 4-slice toaster with extra-wide slots, a wide range of shades, Bagel, Defrost, Reheat and Little Longer functions, a manual high-lift lever and a bagel mode that toasts the cut side while warming the outside; it weighs 7.4 lb.

Pros

  • Little Longer button
  • One-sided bagel toasting
  • Heavy, solid build

Cons

  • 7.4 lb
  • Shade count not stated

Good fit if

  • You want a sturdy 4-slice from a big brand

Skip if

  • Counter space is tight

Verdict: Built for four-slice family mornings.

Best retro

Smeg 2-Slice Toaster Red

Best for: Design-led kitchens

Capacity
2-slice
Cooking Functions
4 functions
Browning Levels
6 levels
Color
Red
Dimensions
12.7 × 7.6 × 7.72 inches
Weight
5 pounds

View on Amazon: Smeg 2-Slice Toaster Red Affiliate link

The Smeg TSF01RDUS in red is the classic 1950s-style 2-slice: two extra-wide slots, 6 browning levels, a backlit chrome knob for reheat, defrost, cancel and bagel, self-centering racks, a stainless crumb tray, a powder-coated steel body, anti-slip feet and cord wrap.

Pros

  • Iconic styling in red
  • Backlit chrome function knob
  • Stainless crumb tray resists stains

Cons

  • Only 6 shades
  • 5 lb for a 2-slice

Good fit if

  • Looks matter as much as toast

Skip if

  • You want a countdown or presets

Verdict: The style choice.

Best touchscreen

All-Clad Stainless Steel Toaster, 2 Slot, Removable Crumb Tray, 850 Watts, 7 Browning Levels, Intuitive Touchscreen, Extra High Lift, Silver

Best for: Minimalist kitchens

Capacity
2-Slice
Control Type
Touchscreen
Color
Stainless Steel
Dimensions
12.8 × 7.76 × 7.76 inches
Weight
4.5 pounds

View on Amazon: All-Clad Stainless Steel Toaster, 2 Slot, Removable Crumb Tray, 850 Watts, 7 Browning Levels, Intuitive Touchscreen, Extra High Lift, Silver Affiliate link

The All-Clad TJ883D51 is an 850W stainless 2-slot toaster with a touchscreen and countdown, 7 browning levels, defrost and reheat, a Favorites option that stores two browning levels, an extra-high lift, an anti-fingerprint finish and a removable crumb tray.

Pros

  • Countdown on a touchscreen
  • Two saved favourites
  • Anti-fingerprint finish

Cons

  • 850W is modest
  • No bagel mode listed

Good fit if

  • You want a clean touchscreen 2-slice at the low end of this band

Skip if

  • Bagels are your main use

Verdict: A tidy, modern 2-slice.

Best fast toast

HeatMate Large 2-Slice Graphite Toaster

Best for: Rushed mornings

Capacity
2-slice
Cooking Functions
3 functions
Browning Levels
7 settings
Heating Technology
Graphite
Size
Large
Intended Use
Bagels

View on Amazon: HeatMate Large 2-Slice Graphite Toaster Affiliate link

The HeatMate 324330 in olive and brushed nickel is a 2-slice pop-up toaster with graphite heating that HeatMate says toasts 30 percent faster, 7 heat settings, toast, defrost and reheat functions, a one-sided bagel mode, a dust cover and tongs.

Pros

  • Graphite elements heat instantly
  • Dust cover and tongs included
  • One-sided bagel mode

Cons

  • 15.8 inches long
  • Speed claim is the maker's own

Good fit if

  • You want quicker toast and an unusual colour

Skip if

  • Counter length is limited

Verdict: The quick-heating option.

Best long slot

Kenmore Elite 4-Slice Long Slot Toaster Silver, One-Touch Auto-Lift, Stainless Steel, Adjustable Browning, Defrost, Digital Countdown Timer, Retractable Cord, Toast, Bagels, Waffles, English Muffins

Best for: Long artisan slices

Capacity
4-Slice
Cooking Function
Toast, Defrost
Control Type
Digital
Color
Silver
Intended Use
Waffles
Features
Long Slot

View on Amazon: Kenmore Elite 4-Slice Long Slot Toaster Silver, One-Touch Auto-Lift, Stainless Steel, Adjustable Browning, Defrost, Digital Countdown Timer, Retractable Cord, Toast, Bagels, Waffles, English Muffins Affiliate link

The Kenmore Elite KKELST4SS, sold by Koolatron under the Kenmore name, is a 4-slice long-slot toaster with self-adjusting guides, one-touch auto-lift, 9 browning options, bagel, warm, defrost and one-slot modes, a digital countdown, raise-and-check and a retractable cord.

Pros

  • Auto-lift lowers and raises bread
  • 9 browning options
  • Retractable cord

Cons

  • 15.5 inches long
  • Two near-identical listings exist

Good fit if

  • You toast artisan loaves and want automation

Skip if

  • You want separate short slots

Verdict: The most automated 4-slice here.

Also great

Waring Extra-Long Slot 4-Slice Toaster

Best for: Busy kitchens

Capacity
4-Slice
Slot Width
1-3/8-inch
Cooking Function
Defrost, Reheat
Voltage
120V
Use
Commercial Use
Color
Silver

View on Amazon: Waring Extra-Long Slot 4-Slice Toaster Affiliate link

The Waring WCT704 is a chrome-plated steel light-duty toaster with two extra-long 1-3/8-inch slots for four slices, a self-centering rack, a rotary browning dial, LED-lit defrost, reheat and cancel keys and a pull-out crumb tray.

Pros

  • Commercial-grade build
  • Extra-long slots
  • Self-centering rack

Cons

  • 18.5 inches long
  • No bagel mode

Good fit if

  • You want a durable long-slot toaster

Skip if

  • Digital presets are on your list

Verdict: Simple and tough.

Specifications side by side

Spec Breville 2-Slice Die-Cast Smart Toaster KitchenAid 4-Slice Pro Line Automatic Toaster, KMT4109, Cast Iron Black | Fits Bagels, English Muffins, Thick Breads, Seven Shade Settings, Metal Housing, Auto Lift Lever Smeg 2-Slice Toaster Red All-Clad Stainless Steel Toaster, 2 Slot, Removable Crumb Tray, 850 Watts, 7 Browning Levels, Intuitive Touchscreen, Extra High Lift, Silver HeatMate Large 2-Slice Graphite Toaster Kenmore Elite 4-Slice Long Slot Toaster Silver, One-Touch Auto-Lift, Stainless Steel, Adjustable Browning, Defrost, Digital Countdown Timer, Retractable Cord, Toast, Bagels, Waffles, English Muffins Waring Extra-Long Slot 4-Slice Toaster
Capacity 2 Slice not stated 2-slice not stated 2-slice not stated 4-Slice
Cooking Functions not stated not stated 4 functions not stated 3 functions not stated not stated
Browning Levels not stated not stated 6 levels not stated 7 settings not stated not stated
Slot Width not stated not stated not stated not stated not stated not stated 1-3/8-inch
Heating Technology not stated not stated not stated not stated Graphite not stated not stated
Wattage 900 Watts not stated not stated not stated not stated not stated not stated
Cooking Function Toast not stated Defrost not stated Toast Toast, Defrost Defrost, Reheat
Control Type not stated not stated not stated Touchscreen not stated Digital not stated
Voltage not stated not stated not stated not stated not stated not stated 120V
Use not stated not stated not stated not stated not stated not stated Commercial Use
Color Stainless Steel Cast Iron Black Red Stainless Steel Olive/Brushed Nickel Silver Silver
Size 2 Slice 4 Slice 2 Slice 2 Slice Touchscreen Large 4 Slice 2 extra long and extra-wide 1-3/8-inch slots
Intended Use Bagels Bagels not stated not stated Bagels Waffles not stated
Features not stated not stated not stated not stated not stated Long Slot Long Slot
Dimensions 11.6 × 8.58 × 7.52 inches 11.4 × 11.8 × 8.3 inches 12.7 × 7.6 × 7.72 inches 12.8 × 7.76 × 7.76 inches 15.8 × 8.4 × 9.2 inches 15.5 × 6 × 8.6 inches 18.5 × 8.25 × 8.75 inches
Weight 5.71 pounds 7.4 pounds 5 pounds 4.5 pounds not stated 5.5 pounds 5.24 pounds
Model BREBTA820XL KMT4109BK TSF01RDUS TJ883D51 324330 KKELST4SS WCT704

Choosing a toaster from $150 to $200

  1. Check-and-continue features

    Breville's Lift & Look and Kenmore's raise-and-check let you peek without cancelling the cycle.

  2. Bagel behaviour

    KitchenAid, HeatMate and Smeg toast one side for bagels; confirm others in the listing.

  3. Long slot versus four short slots

    Long slots suit artisan loaves; four short slots are easier for sandwich bread.

  4. Prices near the limit

    The Breville sits just under $200 and may cross it.

Frequently asked questions

Which toaster under $200 lets you check toast without cancelling?

The Breville BTA820XL with Lift & Look, and the Kenmore Elite with raise-and-check.

What does Little Longer do on the KitchenAid KMT4109?

It adds a short extra burst of toasting after the cycle.

Does the Smeg TSF01 have a bagel setting?

Yes, on its backlit chrome knob, along with reheat, defrost and cancel.

How many browning levels does the Kenmore Elite KKELST4SS offer?

Nine.

What makes the HeatMate toaster different?

Graphite heating elements that HeatMate says toast 30 percent faster.

See also