As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure

7 Best Toasters Under $300, Compared

Latest update:

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.

We compared 7 pop-up toasters priced between $200 and $300 when we checked; those from $150 to $200 are in our under-$200 list. Our top pick is the Magimix Vision 11526LC, whose glass sides let you watch the bread while four replaceable quartz elements do the work, with 8 levels and a one-side mode for bagels. The Dualit Design Series 46555 is the clever 4-slot, Smeg offers three models (long-slot TSF02, dual-control TSF03 and the 2-slice TSF01), and the Waring WCT708 and Proctor Silex Commercial 24855 suit heavy use. Conveyor toasters and discontinued models are not included; picks come from listings.

Our top pick: Magimix Vision 2-Slice Glass Toaster.

Quick picks

#ProductBest forPrice
1 Magimix Vision 2-Slice Glass Toaster Best overall Toast watchers Check price of Magimix Vision 2-Slice Glass Toaster on Amazon
2 Dualit Design Series 4-Slice Toaster Best 4-slice Families who like thick toast Check price of Dualit Design Series 4-Slice Toaster on Amazon
3 Smeg 4-Slice Long Slot Toaster Best long slot Artisan bread Check price of Smeg 4-Slice Long Slot Toaster on Amazon
4 SMEG 4-Slice Toaster 1800W Also great Shared breakfasts Check price of SMEG 4-Slice Toaster 1800W on Amazon
5 SMEG 2 Slice Toaster with 6 Presets and Defrost Function and Removable Crumb Tray TSF01PGUS, Pastel Green Best 2-slice Pastel-themed kitchens Check price of SMEG 2 Slice Toaster with 6 Presets and Defrost Function and Removable Crumb Tray TSF01PGUS, Pastel Green on Amazon
6 Waring 4-Slot Extra-Wide Toaster Best commercial Bed and breakfasts Check price of Waring 4-Slot Extra-Wide Toaster on Amazon
7 Proctor Silex Commercial 4-Slot Toaster Also great Small cafés Check price of Proctor Silex Commercial 4-Slot Toaster on Amazon

The best fit for you

Our 7 picks

Best overall

Magimix Vision 2-Slice Glass Toaster

Best for: Toast watchers

Capacity
two slices
Cooking Functions
4 pre-programmed settings
Browning Levels
8 toasting levels
Heating Technology
quartz heating elements
Wattage
1450 Watt
Color
Stainless Steel

View on Amazon: Magimix Vision 2-Slice Glass Toaster Affiliate link

The Magimix Vision 11526LC is a chrome stainless toaster with borosilicate glass sides so you can watch the bread, one extra-wide slot for a baguette, bagels or two slices, four commercial replaceable quartz elements, 8 toasting levels, toast-both-sides, toast-one-side, defrost and reheat programs, a stop button, an extra-lift lever and a 3-year warranty.

Pros

  • Glass walls show the toast
  • Replaceable quartz elements
  • 3-year warranty

Cons

  • 9.5 lb
  • Crumb tray is hand-wash

Good fit if

  • You want to see your toast and keep the toaster for years

Skip if

  • You need four separate slots

Verdict: Our top pick from $200 to $300.

Best 4-slice

Dualit Design Series 4-Slice Toaster

Best for: Families who like thick toast

Capacity
4-slice
Slot Width
1.4 in
Cooking Function
Toast
Features
Extra-Wide Slots
Dimensions
11.5 × 11 × 8.1 inches
Weight
9 pounds

View on Amazon: Dualit Design Series 4-Slice Toaster Affiliate link

The Dualit Design Series 46555 is a polished stainless 4-slot toaster with black trim, Perfect Toast technology that adjusts the cycle to the toaster's and the room's temperature, Peek & Pop to check bread mid-cycle, 1.4-inch slots, a one-sided bagel setting, defrost, a crumb tray and swappable colour panels.

Pros

  • Cycle adapts to temperature
  • Peek & Pop lever
  • Interchangeable panels

Cons

  • 9 lb
  • Close to $300 and low stock

Good fit if

  • You want a premium 4-slot with clever controls

Skip if

  • You prefer a long slot

Verdict: The smart 4-slot.

Best long slot

Smeg 4-Slice Long Slot Toaster

Best for: Artisan bread

Capacity
4-slice
Browning Levels
6 levels
Slot Width
1.4 in
Wattage
1400 W
Cooking Function
Defrost, Reheat
Intended Use
Bagels

View on Amazon: Smeg 4-Slice Long Slot Toaster Affiliate link

The Smeg TSF02PBUS in pastel blue is a 4-slice long-slot toaster with two 1.4-inch slots for sourdough and Texas toast, 6 browning levels, backlit bagel, defrost and reheat buttons and a single control panel; Smeg's TSSR02 sandwich racks fit it (sold separately).

Pros

  • Long slots for artisan loaves
  • Backlit one-touch buttons
  • Space-saving long shape

Cons

  • One control for all four slices
  • 10.1 lb

Good fit if

  • You want Smeg styling with room for long bread

Skip if

  • You want each side set separately

Verdict: Retro looks with long slots.

Also great

SMEG 4-Slice Toaster 1800W

Best for: Shared breakfasts

Capacity
4 Slice
Browning Levels
6 Browning Levels
Slot Width
1.4”
Wattage
1800W
Cooking Function
Defrost, Reheat
Intended Use
Bagels

View on Amazon: SMEG 4-Slice Toaster 1800W Affiliate link

The Smeg TSF03PBUS in pastel blue is a 4-slice toaster with four 1.4-inch slots, dual independent controls, 6 browning levels, bagel, defrost and reheat buttons, and compatibility with Smeg TSSR01 sandwich racks (sold separately).

Pros

  • Each pair of slots set separately
  • 1.4-inch slots
  • Sandwich-rack compatible

Cons

  • 8 lb
  • Low stock

Good fit if

  • Two people want different shades at once

Skip if

  • Long artisan slices matter

Verdict: The Smeg for mixed preferences.

Best 2-slice

SMEG 2 Slice Toaster with 6 Presets and Defrost Function and Removable Crumb Tray TSF01PGUS, Pastel Green

Best for: Pastel-themed kitchens

Capacity
2-Slice
Cooking Function
Defrost
Dimensions
12.7 × 7.6 × 7.72 inches
Weight
5 pounds

View on Amazon: SMEG 2 Slice Toaster with 6 Presets and Defrost Function and Removable Crumb Tray TSF01PGUS, Pastel Green Affiliate link

The Smeg TSF01 in pastel green is the 1950s-style 2-slice: extra-wide slots, 6 browning levels, a backlit chrome knob for reheat, defrost, cancel and bagel, self-centering racks, a stainless crumb tray and an enamelled steel body.

Pros

  • Pastel green enamel
  • Self-centering racks
  • Cord wrap

Cons

  • Only two slices
  • Costs more than the same toaster in red

Good fit if

  • You want a Smeg 2-slice in this colour

Skip if

  • You want value for money

Verdict: Colour is what you pay for.

Best commercial

Waring 4-Slot Extra-Wide Toaster

Best for: Bed and breakfasts

Slot Width
1-3/8-inch
Voltage
120V
Color
Silver
Intended Use
Bread
Dimensions
4.5 × 16 × 4.5 inches
Weight
7.52 pounds

View on Amazon: Waring 4-Slot Extra-Wide Toaster Affiliate link

The Waring WCT708 is a brushed steel light-duty commercial toaster with four extra-wide 1-3/8-inch slots, four self-centering racks, electronic browning control, a removable crumb tray and a rated output of 225 slices per hour.

Pros

  • 225 slices per hour
  • Four self-centering racks
  • Brushed steel build

Cons

  • Plain styling
  • 7.5 lb

Good fit if

  • You toast in quantity, such as a breakfast room

Skip if

  • You want bagel presets

Verdict: A workhorse for frequent use.

Also great

Proctor Silex Commercial 4-Slot Toaster

Best for: Small cafés

Temperature Range
up to 450°F
Slot Width
1 3/8-inch
Use
Commercial Use
Dimensions
12.3 × 12.4 × 8.38 inches
Weight
6.1 pounds

View on Amazon: Proctor Silex Commercial 4-Slot Toaster Affiliate link

The Proctor Silex Commercial 24855 is an NSF-certified stainless 4-slot toaster with 1-3/8-inch slots, longer-life heating elements, bread-centering guides, Toast Boost to raise finished toast, controls adjustable to 450°F and two front crumb trays.

Pros

  • NSF certified
  • Two front crumb trays
  • Toast Boost

Cons

  • No bagel or defrost function listed
  • Commercial look

Good fit if

  • You need a rated toaster for a small café or office

Skip if

  • You want home-style presets

Verdict: The cheapest 4-slot pro here.

Specifications side by side

Spec Magimix Vision 2-Slice Glass Toaster Dualit Design Series 4-Slice Toaster Smeg 4-Slice Long Slot Toaster SMEG 4-Slice Toaster 1800W SMEG 2 Slice Toaster with 6 Presets and Defrost Function and Removable Crumb Tray TSF01PGUS, Pastel Green Waring 4-Slot Extra-Wide Toaster Proctor Silex Commercial 4-Slot Toaster
Capacity two slices 4-slice 4-slice 4 Slice not stated not stated not stated
Cooking Functions 4 pre-programmed settings not stated not stated not stated not stated not stated not stated
Temperature Range not stated not stated not stated not stated not stated not stated up to 450°F
Browning Levels 8 toasting levels not stated 6 levels 6 Browning Levels not stated not stated not stated
Slot Width not stated 1.4 in 1.4 in 1.4” not stated 1-3/8-inch 1 3/8-inch
Heating Technology quartz heating elements not stated not stated not stated not stated not stated not stated
Wattage 1450 Watt not stated 1400 W 1800W not stated not stated not stated
Cooking Function not stated Toast Defrost, Reheat Defrost, Reheat Defrost not stated not stated
Voltage not stated not stated not stated not stated not stated 120V not stated
Use not stated not stated not stated not stated not stated not stated Commercial Use
Color Stainless Steel Black Body & Stainless Steel Panels Pastel Blue Pastel Blue Pastel Green Silver Stainless-Steel
Size not stated 4 slot 4 Slice 4 Slice 2 Slice 4-Compartment 4 Slots
Intended Use not stated not stated Bagels Bagels not stated Bread not stated
Features not stated Extra-Wide Slots Long Slot not stated not stated not stated not stated
Dimensions 7 × 15.6 × 8.9 inches 11.5 × 11 × 8.1 inches 8 × 16 × 9 inches 13 × 12 × 8 inches 12.7 × 7.6 × 7.72 inches 4.5 × 16 × 4.5 inches 12.3 × 12.4 × 8.38 inches
Weight 9.5 pounds 9 pounds 10.1 pounds 8 pounds 5 pounds 7.52 pounds 6.1 pounds
Model 11526LC 46555 TSF02PBUS TSF03PBUS TSF01 WCT708 24855

Choosing a toaster from $200 to $300

  1. Repairable parts

    Magimix's quartz elements are replaceable, which matters at this price.

  2. Same Smeg, different price

    Smeg colours vary in price for the same TSF01; compare finishes.

  3. Commercial ratings

    NSF or slices-per-hour ratings mean a toaster is built for constant use, not for presets.

  4. Sandwich racks

    Smeg's TSSR racks are sold separately.

Frequently asked questions

Which toaster under $300 lets you see the bread?

The Magimix Vision 11526LC, with borosilicate glass sides.

What does Dualit's Perfect Toast technology do?

It measures the toaster's and room's temperature and adjusts the cycle.

What is the difference between the Smeg TSF02 and TSF03?

The TSF02 has two long slots and one control panel; the TSF03 has four slots with dual independent controls.

How many slices per hour can the Waring WCT708 toast?

225, according to Waring.

Is the Proctor Silex 24855 NSF certified?

Yes, it is NSF approved for hotels and restaurants.

See also