As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure

Betty Crocker BC-2958CS Pizza Maker Plus 12-Inch Review

Latest update:

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.

The Betty Crocker Pizza Maker Plus BC-2958CS is a 12-inch electric clamshell cooker in silver: a nonstick plate and a heated lid close over the food, powered by 1440W. Our verdict: a handy, low-cost way to make 12-inch homemade pizzas and flatbreads without turning on the oven, and its real strength is the 'Plus' side, as a griddle for quesadillas, panini, crepes and pancakes. It is not an oven, so crust and toppings cook by contact rather than by hot air. We describe it from Betty Crocker's listing, not from our own use.

What stands out

  • 12 in nonstick plate
  • Heated hinged lid
  • 1440W
  • 5.5 lb

Who it fits

Good fit for

Families who want fast homemade pizzas and a flat griddle for snacks.

Who should skip it

Pizza fans chasing a crisp stone-baked crust, and buyers in the states the listing excludes.

Verdict: Great value as a pizza-and-griddle gadget; not a substitute for an oven.

Betty Crocker BC-2958CS specs

BC-2958CS cooking area: 12 in round

Fits a standard 12 in homemade pizza or a large tortilla.

BC-2958CS power: 1440W

Heats plate and lid together for top and bottom cooking.

BC-2958CS footprint: 15.9 x 13.8 x 5 in, 5.5 lb

Low and light enough to slide into a cupboard.

BC-2958CS shipping limits

Not sold to CO, CT, IL, ME, MD, MN, NM, RI or VT.

A silver clamshell with a heated lid

The BC-2958CS looks like an oversized waffle maker: a round 12-inch nonstick plate in a silver body, closed by a domed lid that also heats. At about 5 in tall and 5.5 lb, it is easy to lift onto a table or store on a shelf. Betty Crocker sells the same Pizza Maker Plus in red as the BC-2958CR; the silver one blends better with stainless appliances.

Pizza night and beyond

Lay the dough on the plate, add toppings, close the lid and cook; both surfaces heat at once, so thin crusts cook in minutes. On other days, the flat plate makes quesadillas, pancakes, crepes, s'mores or giant cookies, and the lid presses panini. Cleanup is a hand wash of the nonstick surface; the listing does not mention removable plates.

Before buying the Betty Crocker BC-2958CS

A few checks.

Check before you buy

  • Whether you are in a state the BC-2958CS cannot ship to
  • That 12 in is the largest pizza you make on the BC-2958CS
  • That hand-washing the BC-2958CS plate is fine for you
  • Whether the red BC-2958CR suits your kitchen better

The product at a glance

Betty Crocker 12-Inch Electric Pizza Maker

Best for: Kids' pizza nights and quick snacks

Internal Capacity
12" pizza
Wattage
1440 W
Cooking Function
Grill
Color
Silver
Dimensions
15.9 × 13.8 × 5 inches
Weight
5.5 pounds

View on Amazon: Betty Crocker 12-Inch Electric Pizza Maker Affiliate link

The Betty Crocker BC-2958CS Pizza Maker Plus is a silver 12-inch electric clamshell: a nonstick plate below and a hinged lid above, both heated by a 1440W element. It is not an oven but a countertop griddle that bakes 12-inch pizzas and flatbreads and also handles quesadillas, pancakes, panini, crepes, tortillas and giant cookies. It weighs 5.5 lb and measures about 15.9 x 13.8 x 5 in.

Pros

  • 12 in pizzas without heating the main oven
  • 1440W heats both plate and lid
  • Doubles as a quesadilla, panini and pancake griddle
  • Light at 5.5 lb, easy to store flat

Cons

  • Clamshell griddle, not a countertop oven: no bake rack or roasting
  • Hand wash only per the listing
  • Not sold in nine US states because of PFAS rules

Good fit if

  • You want quick homemade 12 in pizzas, flatbreads and quesadillas in a cheap, storable appliance

Skip if

  • You want a crisp, stone-baked crust or an oven that also roasts and toasts

Verdict: A cheap, versatile flat cooker for pizza nights and snacks.

Specifications side by side

Spec Betty Crocker 12-Inch Electric Pizza Maker
Internal Capacity 12" pizza
Wattage 1440 W
Capacity Full Size
Cooking Function Grill
Color Silver
Dimensions 15.9 × 13.8 × 5 inches
Weight 5.5 pounds
Size Full Size
Model BC-2958CS

Frequently asked questions

Is the Betty Crocker Pizza Maker Plus an oven?

No. It is an electric clamshell griddle with a heated lid; it cooks by contact rather than by circulating air.

What size pizza fits the BC-2958CS?

Pizzas up to 12 inches.

What else can the Pizza Maker Plus cook?

Quesadillas, pancakes, panini, crepes, tortillas, nachos, s'mores and giant cookies, according to the listing.

Which states can the BC-2958CS not ship to?

Colorado, Connecticut, Illinois, Maine, Maryland, Minnesota, New Mexico, Rhode Island and Vermont, due to PFAS rules.

See also