6 Best Alternatives to the Chefman 12-Inch 1440W Pizza Maker (2026)

How each alternative compares

Betty Crocker 12-Inch Pizza Maker and Grill

The Betty Crocker 12-Inch Pizza Maker and Grill uses the same 1440W power as the Chefman but offers a different form factor. It stands 3.5 inches tall, making it slightly shorter than the Chefman’s 4-inch height. Its footprint is 13 inches wide by 16 inches long, which is one inch longer than the Chefman. The unit weighs 5.7 pounds, slightly lighter than the Chefman’s 6 pounds. It features a white finish instead of concrete. You get a dedicated grill function alongside pizza making. If you prefer a white aesthetic and a lower profile, this model fits your counter space well. It lacks the versatile cooking plates of the Chefman, focusing instead on straightforward grilling and pizza tasks.

NutriChef 12-Inch 1500W Countertop Cooker

The NutriChef 12-Inch Countertop Cooker provides 1500W of power, which is higher than the Chefman’s 1440W. This extra wattage may help with faster heating. However, the physical dimensions differ significantly. It measures 16.3 inches wide by 13.07 inches deep and 5.03 inches high. This makes it taller and wider than the Chefman. The unit is available in red, offering a distinct color choice. It weighs approximately the same as the Chefman, though exact weight is not listed. The model number is NCSW837RED. You might choose this if you want a slightly more powerful heating element and do not mind a bulkier footprint. It is designed for quick personal pizza preparation. The larger size may require more counter space than the compact Chefman unit.

Kitchen Elite Compact 800W Toaster Oven

The Kitchen Elite Compact Toaster Oven operates at only 800W, significantly less than the Chefman’s 1440W. This lower wattage means slower heating and cooking times. It is designed for small kitchens with basic cooking needs. The dimensions are 13.2 inches wide by 10.2 inches long and 7.5 inches high. It is taller than the Chefman but narrower in length. The finish is stainless steel, contrasting with the Chefman’s concrete look. It is labeled as a compact size toaster oven rather than a dedicated pizza maker. You should pick this if you need a versatile appliance for light baking and toasting. It sacrifices the high-heat capability and specific pizza-making features of the Chefman for a smaller, multi-use form factor.

Baker's Friend 12-Inch 1400W Pizza Maker

The Baker's Friend 12-Inch Pizza Maker runs at 1400W, slightly less than the Chefman’s 1440W. The difference is minimal but may affect cooking speed. It shares the same footprint of 15 inches by 13 inches and a similar height of 3.9 inches. It weighs 5.5 pounds, lighter than the Chefman’s 6 pounds. The color is graphite, offering a dark alternative to the concrete finish. The model is BF2-12PM01G. This unit is designed for simple, quick pizza and quesadilla cooking. It lacks the multi-cooker versatility of the Chefman, focusing solely on pizza tasks. You might choose this if you prefer a slightly lighter unit with a graphite aesthetic. It provides straightforward operation without the advanced features found in the Chefman Everything Maker.

Proctor Silex 4-Slice Toaster Oven

The Proctor Silex 4-Slice Toaster Oven is a traditional countertop oven, not a dedicated pizza maker. It weighs 8.15 pounds, much heavier than the Chefman. Its dimensions are 15.2 inches wide by 8.07 inches long and 11.3 inches high. It is significantly taller and deeper than the compact Chefman unit. The finish is black and silver. It includes a 30-minute timer and auto-shutoff feature. This appliance is better suited for basic toasting and small batch baking. It lacks the direct-contact cooking plates of the Chefman, which are designed for crisp pizza crusts. You should pick this if you need a general-purpose oven for various foods. It is not ideal for pizza enthusiasts who want quick, specialized results.

Baker’s Friend 12-Inch Pizza Maker with Temp Control

The Baker’s Friend 12-Inch Pizza Maker with Temp Control offers manual temperature control, a feature not explicitly detailed in the Chefman’s specs. It shares the same dimensions as the standard Baker's Friend model: 15 inches wide by 13 inches long and 3.9 inches high. It weighs 5.5 pounds. The color is graphite. The model number is BF2-12PMTC01G. This unit is designed for users who value manual precision over digital convenience. It provides a smaller footprint similar to the Chefman. You might choose this if you prefer adjusting heat settings manually. It lacks the multi-function cooking plates of the Chefman, focusing on pizza and similar flatbreads. The manual control offers a different user experience compared to the Chefman’s preset approach.

Quick picks

Our 7 picks

1 Best overall

Chefman 12-Inch 1440W Pizza Maker

Best for: Quick cooking of 12-inch pizzas

Internal Capacity

12-inch pizza

Temperature Range

Up to 428°F

Wattage

1440W

Heating Elements

Top and bottom electric skillets

Dimensions

15 × 13 × 4 inches

Weight

6 pounds

View on Amazon: Chefman 12-Inch 1440W Pizza Maker Affiliate link

This 1440W countertop appliance cooks 12-inch pizzas and other items using top and bottom electric skillets. It heats to 428°F in about 3 minutes. The nonstick plates wipe clean easily. It stands vertically to save space. You get a digital cookbook with fifteen recipes. It fits small kitchens well.

Pros

• 1440W heating power
• Reaches 428°F
• Heats up in 3 minutes
• Stands vertically for storage
• Includes 15 recipes

Cons

• Limited to 12-inch capacity
• No digital temperature control
• Nonstick coating requires gentle care

Good fit if

• You want to cook 12-inch pizzas
• You need a compact countertop appliance
• You prefer quick preheating times

Skip if

• You need to cook larger pizzas
• You require precise temperature settings
• You want a stainless steel finish

Verdict: Chefman Everything Maker 12-Inch Pizza Oven suits those who value speed and space savings. It delivers fast cooking for small households without complex controls.

2 Best premium

Betty Crocker 12-Inch Pizza Maker and Grill

Best for: simple 12-inch pizza baking and grilling

Internal Capacity

12-inch pizza

Wattage

1440 W

Cooking Function

Grill

Color

White

Dimensions

16 × 13 × 3.5 inches

Weight

5.7 pounds

View on Amazon: Betty Crocker 12-Inch Pizza Maker and Grill Affiliate link

The Betty Crocker 12" Pizza Maker Plus is a 1440W countertop appliance designed for baking 12-inch pizzas and grilling. It features a 13 by 16 by 3.5-inch footprint and weighs 5.7 pounds. The nonstick surface supports various foods like quesadillas and paninis. It suits those who want a dedicated pizza device that also handles light grilling tasks without using a main oven.

Pros

• 1440W heating element for consistent cooking
• 12-inch internal capacity fits standard pizzas
• Nonstick surface simplifies hand washing
• Versatile functions include grilling and baking

Cons

• No visible temperature control dial in specs
• Limited to countertop use without oven
• Basic grill function lacks precision settings

Good fit if

• You want a dedicated 12-inch pizza maker
• You prefer simple nonstick cleanup
• You need a 1440W unit for steady heat

Skip if

• You require precise temperature regulation
• You need a convection or toaster oven
• You want a compact travel size

Verdict: Betty Crocker 12" Pizza Maker Plus offers a straightforward 1440W solution for home pizza lovers who value easy cleanup over advanced cooking controls. It fits users seeking a single-purpose appliance for quick, oven-free meals.

3 Also great

NutriChef 12-Inch 1500W Countertop Cooker

Best for: Quick personal pizza preparation

Internal Capacity

12" pizza

Temperature Range

175-400°F

Wattage

1500 W

Cooking Function

Toast

Color

Red

Dimensions

5.04 × 16.3 × 13.1 inches

View on Amazon: NutriChef 12-Inch 1500W Countertop Cooker Affiliate link

This NutriChef countertop pizza maker delivers 1500 watts of power to cook 12-inch personal pizzas. It features a temperature range of 175 to 400°F and a non-stick aluminum plate. The unit measures 16.3 inches wide and 13.1 inches high. You get a compact design with cool-touch handles. It includes a spatula for serving. This model suits you if you want quick, customizable meals on a flat surface.

Pros

• 1500W heating element for quick temperature recovery
• Adjustable 175-400°F temperature range for versatile cooking
• Non-stick aluminum plate for easy cleanup
• Includes spatula for effortless serving

Cons

• Maximum temperature of 400°F is lower than many competitors
• Flat plate design limits browning compared to enclosed ovens
• No timer or automatic shut-off feature listed

Good fit if

• You want to make 12-inch personal pizzas quickly
• You prefer flat-surface cooking over enclosed baking
• You need a compact unit for small counters

Skip if

• You require high-heat baking above 400°F
• You want to cook multiple pizzas at once
• You need precise temperature control for delicate items

Verdict: NutriChef 12-Inch Pizza Maker offers solid power for its size, making it a good fit for households that prioritize speed and easy cleanup for single-pizza meals. It works best for casual pizza nights rather than serious baking.

4 Best stainless steel

Kitchen Elite Compact 800W Toaster Oven

Best for: small kitchens with basic cooking needs

Temperature Range

200°F–450°F

Wattage

800 W

Cooking Function

Bake, Toast

Color

Stainless Steel

Dimensions

10.2 × 13.2 × 7.5 inches

View on Amazon: Kitchen Elite Compact 800W Toaster Oven Affiliate link

The Kitchen Elite Compact Toaster Oven offers 800 watts of power for baking, toasting, and broiling. It features a temperature range from 200°F to 450°F and measures 13.2 by 10.2 by 7.5 inches. This stainless steel unit is designed for small spaces. It includes a slide-out crumb tray and cool-touch handle for safe operation. You should choose this model if you need a basic, energy-efficient appliance for light daily cooking tasks.

Pros

• 800-watt heating system for efficient cooking
• Adjustable temperature range from 200°F to 450°F
• Compact dimensions fit small counters
• Cool-touch handle for safe operation

Cons

• Lower 800-watt power compared to high-performance pizza makers
• Limited to basic bake, toast, and broil functions
• No digital timer or precise temperature display visible in data

Good fit if

• You have limited counter space
• You need a basic appliance for toasting and reheating
• You prefer manual temperature control

Skip if

• You require high-wattage power for fast pizza cooking
• You need advanced digital controls or presets
• You want to cook large or multiple items at once

Verdict: Kitchen Elite Compact Toaster Oven is a small, manual appliance for light cooking. It suits users who prioritize space savings over high power or advanced features.

5 Best budget

Baker's Friend 12-Inch 1400W Pizza Maker

Best for: Simple, quick pizza and quesadilla cooking

Internal Capacity

12"

Wattage

1400W

Heating Elements

Dual cooking plates

Dimensions

13 × 15 × 3.9 inches

Weight

5.5 pounds

View on Amazon: Baker's Friend 12-Inch 1400W Pizza Maker Affiliate link

The Baker's Friend 12-inch pizza maker uses 1400W dual heating plates to cook frozen or fresh dough quickly. It measures 15 by 13 inches and weighs 5.5 pounds. The graphite unit stands 3.9 inches tall. Dual indicator lights show power and preheat status. It fits users who want a dedicated appliance for pizzas, quesadillas, and sandwiches without using a full oven.

Pros

• 1400W dual heating plates for rapid, even cooking
• 12-inch internal capacity for standard-sized pizzas
• Non-stick surfaces for easy cleanup
• Dual indicator lights for power and preheat status
• Upright storage design to save counter space

Cons

• Lower wattage than 1440W competitors on this list
• No timer or temperature control settings listed
• Limited to one thickness setting for cooking

Good fit if

• You want a dedicated machine for quick pizza nights
• You need a compact appliance for small kitchens
• You prefer simple operation with indicator lights

Skip if

• You require precise temperature control for baking
• You need a timer for automated cooking
• You want the highest wattage for fastest heating

Verdict: Baker's Friend 12-Inch Countertop Pizza Maker offers straightforward cooking for users who prioritize simplicity and space-saving design over advanced controls. It suits those who want quick results for pizzas and quesadillas without complex settings.

6 Best 4-slice

Proctor Silex 4-Slice Toaster Oven

Best for: basic toasting and small batch baking

Internal Capacity

4 slices of bread

Cooking Functions

3-in-1

Temperature Range

200-450°F

Control Type

Manual controls

Dimensions

8.07 × 15.2 × 11.3 inches

Weight

8.15 pounds

View on Amazon: Proctor Silex 4-Slice Toaster Oven Affiliate link

The Proctor Silex 4-slice toaster oven offers three cooking functions: toast, broil, and bake. It fits four slices of bread and measures 15.2 by 8.07 by 11.3 inches. You get manual controls and a 30-minute timer with an auto-shutoff feature. The unit weighs 8.15 pounds and includes a bake pan and oven rack. It suits you if you want basic, straightforward countertop cooking without digital interfaces.

Pros

• Toasts four slices of bread simultaneously
• Includes both a bake pan and an oven rack
• Features a 30-minute timer with auto-shutoff
• Has a removable crumb tray for easy cleaning

Cons

• Only offers three basic cooking functions
• Uses manual dials instead of digital controls
• No internal light or window mentioned in specifications

Good fit if

• You need a simple appliance for basic toasting and baking
• You prefer manual controls over digital interfaces
• You want a compact unit for a small kitchen

Skip if

• You require advanced cooking presets or convection
• You want a larger capacity for family meals
• You need precise digital temperature control

Verdict: Proctor Silex 4-Slice Countertop Toaster Oven fits you if you need a no-frills appliance for simple toasting and baking tasks. It lacks the versatility of the other pizza makers on this list, making it a poor choice for pizza enthusiasts.

7 Also great

Baker’s Friend 12-Inch Pizza Maker with Temp Control

Best for: Manual temperature control lovers

Internal Capacity

12-inch

Wattage

1400 W

Control Type

Heat control knob

Dimensions

13 × 15 × 3.9 inches

Weight

5.5 pounds

View on Amazon: Baker’s Friend 12-Inch Pizza Maker with Temp Control Affiliate link

This 1400W electric pizza maker cooks 12-inch pizzas in minutes. It features a non-stick plate and a heat control knob for precise temperature adjustments. The compact 15x13x3.9-inch design fits easily on counters. It also handles quesadillas, omelets, and pancakes. You get versatile cooking in a space-saving footprint.

Pros

• 1400W heating element for quick cooking
• 12-inch non-stick cooking surface
• Adjustable heat control knob
• Compact 5.5-pound build
• Multi-functional for quesadillas and eggs

Cons

• Lower wattage than 1440W competitors
• No digital display or timer
• Manual heat control only

Good fit if

• You want precise temperature control
• You need a compact appliance
• You cook versatile flatbreads

Skip if

• You need digital controls
• You want faster heating
• You prefer a timer

Verdict: Baker's Friend 12-Inch Electric Pizza Maker offers manual precision in a small footprint. It suits those who value temperature control over digital convenience.

Specifications side by side

Frequently asked questions

See also

• chefman coffee maker espresso machine alternatives
• chefman small alternatives