Looking Beyond the Betty Crocker 12-Inch Pizza Maker Grill? 6 Alternatives Worth a Look

Comparing Key Specifications

Nostalgia 8 Hot Dog Roller and Bun Toaster Oven

The Nostalgia Hot Dog Roller is a specialized appliance rather than a general-purpose oven. It measures 8.1 by 13.5 by 7.6 inches and weighs less than the Betty Crocker model. This unit focuses exclusively on grilling hot dogs and toasting buns simultaneously. You give up the ability to bake 12-inch pizzas or grill large items. It fits better in tight counter spaces where dedicated sausage preparation is the primary goal. The red finish matches the original, but the internal capacity is limited to sausages and buns only. Choose this if you serve hot dogs frequently and need a compact, single-task solution.

Commercial CHEF 12-Inch Pizza Maker and Grill

The Commercial CHEF model shares the 12-inch cooking surface and similar dimensions with the Betty Crocker unit. It weighs 6.5 pounds, slightly more than the 5.5-pound original. This model offers variable temperature control, which the original lacks. You gain precise heat adjustment for commercial use or serious home cooking. The nonstick surface and included tools remain similar. This unit is heavier and designed for environments requiring consistent, high-volume output. Pick this alternative if you need exact temperature settings for varied recipes rather than simple on-off grilling. The robust construction supports more intensive daily use.

Zenith 12-Inch 1440W Pizza Maker & Grill

The Zenith Versa Grill matches the 12-inch capacity and 1440W power of the Betty Crocker original. It is smaller in footprint, measuring 12.6 by 14.8 by 3.93 inches. This unit is lighter and more compact, saving counter space. You get straightforward nonstick grilling for pizzas and sandwiches without complex controls. The lack of variable settings simplifies operation. Choose this model if you prefer a minimalist design with easy cleanup. It sacrifices some build mass for portability. The red color and grill function align with the original, making it a direct, streamlined replacement for basic indoor pizza and sandwich preparation.

Cuisinart Air Fryer Toaster Oven with Grill

The Cuisinart TOA-70 is a convection toaster oven with air frying capabilities, differing significantly from the flat grill. It weighs 25.4 pounds and measures 15.8 by 12.3 by 13.8 inches. This unit offers 1800W of power and multiple cooking functions including broil and air fry. You gain versatility for roasting and baking but lose the dedicated flat-surface grilling experience. The stainless steel finish contrasts with the red plastic original. Select this if you need a multi-function appliance for diverse meals. It is larger and heavier, requiring more counter space and storage room.

Nuwave Bravo XL 30-Qt Grill Air Fryer Oven

The Nuwave Bravo XL is a 30-quart air fryer oven with grill capabilities. It weighs 17.8 pounds and measures 12.9 by 20 by 11.1 inches. This unit provides high capacity and precise control for large families. You gain the ability to cook large batches of food using air frying and grilling functions. The stainless steel exterior differs from the original’s red plastic. It is significantly larger and more complex than the Betty Crocker model. Choose this if you prioritize cooking versatility and volume over compact size. It suits households needing to prepare multiple dishes simultaneously with advanced temperature management.

PIEZANO 12-Inch Red Electric Pizza Oven

The PIEZANO 12-Inch Oven is a dedicated pizza oven with a ceramic stone. It measures 14.2 by 14.2 by 14.2 inches and weighs more than the original. This unit delivers high heat for crispy crusts, focusing on baking rather than grilling. You lose the flat-surface versatility for sandwiches or quesadillas. The red finish matches the original, but the internal stone changes the cooking method. Pick this if you value crust texture and serious baking performance. It is a specialized tool for pizza enthusiasts who prioritize crust quality over multi-purpose convenience. The ceramic stone requires specific care and handling.

Quick picks

Our 7 picks

1 Best overall

Betty Crocker 12-Inch Pizza Maker and Grill

Best for: Dedicated 12-inch pizza and grill cooking

Internal Capacity

12-inch pizza

Wattage

1440 W

Cooking Function

Grill

Color

Red

Dimensions

13.8 × 15.9 × 5.04 inches

Weight

5.5 pounds

View on Amazon: Betty Crocker 12-Inch Pizza Maker and Grill

The Betty Crocker Pizza Maker Plus is a 12-inch indoor grill and pizza cooker with 1440W of power. It features a non-stick surface for easy cleaning and handles items like quesadillas, paninis, and flatbreads. Measuring 15.9 by 13.8 inches, it sits on your countertop. This unit suits you if you want a dedicated appliance for quick, oven-less cooking and versatile meal prep.

Pros

• 1440W heating element for fast cooking
• 12-inch cooking surface fits standard pizzas
• Non-stick surface allows for simple hand washing
• Versatile grill function for quesadillas and paninis

Cons

• Limited to grilling and baking functions
• No automated shut-off timer listed in specs
• Bulky footprint at 15.9 inches wide

Good fit if

• You want a dedicated appliance for 12-inch pizzas
• You prefer manual control over cooking times
• You need a versatile grill for flatbreads and quesadillas

Skip if

• You require automated timer settings for unattended cooking
• You have limited countertop space under 16 inches wide
• You need a compact travel-sized unit

Verdict: Betty Crocker 12" Pizza Maker Plus delivers reliable 1440W performance for 12-inch pizzas and versatile grilling tasks. It fits you well if you value a dedicated, easy-to-clean countertop appliance for frequent homemade meals.

2 Best premium

Nostalgia 8 Hot Dog Roller and Bun Toaster Oven

Best for: Dedicated hot dog and bun preparation

Heating Elements

5 stainless steel rollers

Control Type

Adjustable Timer

Cooking Function

Grill

Color

Red

Dimensions

13.5 × 8.1 × 7.6 inches

View on Amazon: Nostalgia 8 Hot Dog Roller and Bun Toaster Oven

This Nostalgia unit combines a five-roller grill with a bun toaster. The stainless steel rollers cook hot dogs evenly while the non-stick racks toast buns. It measures 13.5 by 8.1 by 7.6 inches. You set the cooking time with an adjustable timer. It fits small counters and handles veggie sausages or brats.

Pros

• Five stainless steel rollers for even grilling
• Two non-stick warming racks for buns
• Compact 13.5-inch footprint
• Adjustable timer for simple operation

Cons

• Limited to hot dogs and bun toasting
• No temperature control settings
• Basic plastic and metal build

Good fit if

• You want a dedicated hot dog cooker
• You need a compact appliance for small kitchens
• You prefer simple timer-based operation

Skip if

• You need to cook large batches of food
• You require precise temperature control
• You want a multi-purpose oven

Verdict: Nostalgia Hot Dog Roller & Bun Toaster is a specialized tool for families who frequently serve hot dogs. It fits best on counters where space is tight and you need quick, consistent results for sausages and buns.

3 Best budget

Commercial CHEF 12-Inch Pizza Maker and Grill

Best for: commercial use and precise temperature control

Internal Capacity

12 inch pizzas

Temperature Range

70 to 410 degrees Fahrenheit

Control Type

Variable temperature control

Cooking Function

Grill

Use

Commercial Use

Color

Red

View on Amazon: Commercial CHEF 12-Inch Pizza Maker and Grill

This Commercial CHEF unit is a 12-inch countertop pizza maker designed for commercial use. It features variable temperature control ranging from 70 to 410 degrees Fahrenheit. The 13.8 by 15.9 by 5 inch body weighs 6.5 pounds. You get a nonstick baking plate and a compact pizza cutter. It suits users needing precise heat settings for various recipes beyond just pizza.

Pros

• Variable temperature control from 70 to 410 degrees Fahrenheit
• 12-inch cooking surface for standard pizzas
• Nonstick coated baking plate for easy cleanup
• Includes a compact pizza cutter

Cons

• Limited to 70 degrees minimum, which may not suit all low-temp recipes
• No digital display to show exact temperature settings
• Heavier build at 6.5 pounds compared to lighter home models

Good fit if

• You need precise temperature control for diverse recipes
• You require a unit rated for commercial use
• You want a 12-inch capacity for standard pizzas

Skip if

• You prefer a digital display for temperature monitoring
• You need a unit lighter than 6.5 pounds
• You require a minimum temperature below 70 degrees

Verdict: Commercial CHEF 12 Inch Pizza Maker offers robust variable temperature control for users who need precision. It fits commercial environments or serious home cooks who value nonstick ease and included tools over digital displays.

4 Also great

Zenith 12-Inch 1440W Pizza Maker & Grill

Best for: Simple indoor pizza and sandwich grilling

Internal Capacity

12" pizza

Wattage

1440W

Cooking Function

Grill

Color

Red

Dimensions

14.8 × 12.6 × 3.93 inches

View on Amazon: Zenith 12-Inch 1440W Pizza Maker & Grill

The Zenith Versa Grill is a 12-inch countertop appliance designed for indoor cooking. It operates at 1440W and features a non-stick surface for easy cleanup. The unit measures 14.8 inches in length, 12.6 inches in width, and 3.93 inches in height. You can use it to bake pizzas, make calzones, or prepare sandwiches. This red model fits well on standard counters.

Pros

• 1440W heating element for consistent cooking
• 12-inch capacity for standard pizzas
• Non-stick surface simplifies cleaning
• Versatile functions including grilling and pressing

Cons

• Limited to a single grill function
• No digital timer or temperature display listed
• Manual operation only

Good fit if

• You want a dedicated 12-inch pizza maker
• You prefer simple manual controls
• You need a non-stick surface for easy cleanup

Skip if

• You require digital programming or timers
• You need multiple cooking functions like baking or toasting
• You prefer a stainless steel finish

Verdict: Zenith Versa Grill 12-Inch Pizza Maker suits those who want a straightforward, non-stick appliance for making 12-inch pizzas and sandwiches without complex controls.

5 Best convection

Cuisinart Air Fryer Toaster Oven with Grill

Best for: analog control lovers needing convection air frying

Internal Capacity

0.6 Cubic Feet

Cooking Functions

8-in-1

Temperature Range

Warm-450°F

Wattage

1800W

Convection System

AirAdvantage

Control Type

Adjustable temperature dial

View on Amazon: Cuisinart Air Fryer Toaster Oven with Grill

This Cuisinart model offers 1800 watts of power and an AirAdvantage convection system for fast, crispy results. With a 0.6 cubic foot interior, it fits a 12-inch pizza or a 4-pound chicken. You get eight cooking functions, including air frying and broiling. The stainless steel build includes a reversible grill and griddle. It suits those who want versatile countertop cooking without digital complexity.

Pros

• 1800W heating element for faster cooking
• AirAdvantage convection system for crispy texture
• 0.6 cubic foot capacity fits a 12-inch pizza
• Eight cooking functions including air fry and broil
• Includes air fry basket and reversible grill/griddle

Cons

• Analog dials lack precise temperature control
• No digital display or timer readout
• 25.4 pounds is heavy for frequent moving

Good fit if

• You want convection air frying in a compact footprint
• You prefer analog dials over digital interfaces
• You need to cook a 12-inch pizza or 4-lb chicken

Skip if

• You require precise digital temperature settings
• You need a remote control or app connectivity
• You have limited counter space for a 15.8-inch width

Verdict: Cuisinart TOA-70 1800W Air Fryer Toaster Oven delivers reliable convection performance for households that value analog simplicity and versatile cooking functions over digital precision.

6 Also great

Nuwave Bravo XL 30-Qt Grill Air Fryer Oven

Best for: Large families needing high-capacity versatile cooking

Internal Capacity

30 qt

Cooking Functions

12 functions, 142 presets

Temperature Range

50–500°F

Wattage

1800 W

Heating Elements

Top and bottom heating elements

Convection System

Ultra-Fast Convection

View on Amazon: Nuwave Bravo XL 30-Qt Grill Air Fryer Oven

The Nuwave Bravo XL Pro is a 30-quart air fryer toaster oven with 1800W power. It features an Ultra-Fast Convection System and adjustable top and bottom heating elements. You get 142 presets and a smart thermometer for precise cooking. This unit fits two 13-inch pizzas and includes a reversible grill plate. It suits large families needing versatile countertop cooking.

Pros

• 30-quart internal capacity fits two 13-inch pizzas
• 1800W power with Ultra-Fast Convection System
• Adjustable top and bottom heating element ratios
• Includes smart thermometer for internal temp tracking
• Reversible ceramic non-stick grill and griddle plate

Cons

• Heavier at 17.8 pounds than most pizza makers
• Larger footprint at 20 inches long
• Cool white display lacks color feedback

Good fit if

• You need to cook two 13-inch pizzas at once
• You want adjustable heating zones for specific recipes
• You prefer precise temperature control with a smart probe

Skip if

• You have limited counter space under 12 inches wide
• You only need basic toasting or grilling functions
• You prefer a lighter appliance under 15 pounds

Verdict: Nuwave Bravo XL Pro 30QT Air Fryer offers high capacity and precise control for large households. It is ideal for users who prioritize cooking versatility and speed over compact size.

7 Also great

PIEZANO 12-Inch Red Electric Pizza Oven

Best for: baking crispy crust pizzas at home

Internal Capacity

12"

Temperature Range

Up to 800°F

Color

Red

Dimensions

14.2 × 14.2 × 14.2 inches

View on Amazon: PIEZANO 12-Inch Red Electric Pizza Oven

The Piezano 12-inch pizza oven reaches 800°F to bake pizzeria-style pies in under six minutes. It features a removable natural ceramic stone for even heat transfer and independent top and bottom heat controls. A built-in thermometer display helps you monitor cooking conditions. This countertop unit measures 14.2 inches on each side and includes two peels and a scraper for easy handling.

Pros

• Reaches up to 800°F for crispy crusts
• Includes a removable 12-inch natural ceramic stone
• Independent top and bottom heat settings
• Built-in thermometer display for monitoring
• Comes with two pizza peels and a stone scraper

Cons

• Limited to indoor or outdoor use near an outlet
• No digital timer or programmable shut-off listed
• Manual heat adjustment requires user attention

Good fit if

• You want pizzeria-style crusts at home
• You prefer manual control over temperature
• You need a dedicated stone-baking surface

Skip if

• You need a multi-function air fryer
• You want fully automated cooking cycles
• You require a compact footprint under 12 inches

Verdict: PIEZANO 12" Crispy Crust Pizza Oven delivers high heat and a ceramic stone for serious home bakers who value crust texture over convenience features.

Specifications side by side

Frequently asked questions